ANTI-MIGRANT, FAR-RIGHT AND POPULIST MOBILISATION ALONG THE BALKAN ROUTE

30.10.2020.
By Katja Lihtenvalner

Introduction

Greece has reached boiling point as a result of the steady influx of refugees and migrants, with over 1,2 million people arriving since 2014, intending to make a journey further north[1]Greece sea and land arrivals monthly: Operations Portal. (2020) UNHCR. Available at: https://pr.fo/34HpT00. For people fleeing war, poverty and repression in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia, the Western Balkan route has become one of the main paths into Europe. The sudden arrival of migrants and refugees generally found Balkan countries unprepared.

After Slovenia, Croatia and North Macedonia closed off their borders in early 2016[2]Kingsley, Patrick. (09/03/2016) Balkan countries shut borders as attention turns to new refugee routes. The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/34HlIl2, severely limiting the options for further travel deeper into Europe for the 50,000 plus refugees in Greece[3]According to the International Rescue Committee, Available at: https://pr.fo/2TFsu4j. These people found themselves stranded in Greece, approximately a third of them on islands, but many continue to make the perilous journey via this route. Since then, Slovenia has continued to tighten control at its borders with Croatia. It is gradually extending its fence along the border[4]Fighting over the Slovenian Border Barrier (2020). Deutsche Welle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3hSmm and mobilising additional police units[5]Albert, Rénes. (27/08/2020). Slovenia sends 1,000 police to Croatian border to halt migrant wave. Remix. Available at: https://pr.fo/35UMaH6, which increased the pressure on Croatia especially with regard to its borders with Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH), and Serbia. Subsequently, another bottleneck was created, leaving the authorities in BiH’s North-western Una-Sana Canton to cope with the majority of the 7,000-8,000 migrants who are in the country at any given time, according to an IOM estimate[6]IOM’s Migration Response (2020) IOM Bosnia and Herzegovina. Available at: https://pr.fo/3kJRrrr. A similar situation exists in Serbia’s northern province of Vojvodina, resulting from Hungary’s much larger fence along its southern border and its heavy-handed treatment of refugees.

The current impasse creates unsustainable and often inhumane conditions for everyone trapped behind these fences. Whilst the migrants are bearing the brunt of the consequences of this reality and the failures of the migration and asylum policy in Europe, the situation has also been poisoning the public opinion in the transit countries along the Balkan route, and further. There are two main competing narratives in the media and public discourse, which centre around what are often perceived as irreconcilable, zero sum concerns about the treatment and wellbeing of migrants, particularly the incidents of human rights violations and

violence, and about the safety and security of local population and their property. While media and humanitarian organisations and human rights watchdogs are attempting to raise awareness about the alarming situation on the borders and in refugee camps and reception centres, far-right extremists and populists are using it to create a spectacle that allows them to cast themselves in a role of Europe’s defenders.

This impasse is evolving into a ‘perfect storm’, in which a failing policy and inability to address the root causes of the problem, are creating opportunities for populists and extremists to advance their agendas, enabling criticism of political opponents and mobilisation of supporters.

This advisory brief presents an analysis of the efforts to influence public opinion, and the impact these have had on citizen-mobilisation in the region.


or scroll down to read more


Border Pushback: The Ugly Face of the EU’s Migration Policy

Disturbing reports about the levels of excessive force used against migrants and brutality committed by the Croatian police at the country’s external border began to appear in public from 2016 onwards.

In 2019-2020, various Croatian and international human rights organizations, such as the Human Rights Watch[7]Croatia: Asylum Seekers Forced Back to Serbia (20/01/2017) Human Rights Watch. Available at: https://pr.fo/31XnVa0; Croatia: Migrants Pushed Back to Bosnia and Herzegovina (11/12/2018) Human Rights Watch. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HNxCkq, Amnesty International[8]Croatia: Fresh evidence of police abuse and torture of migrants and asylum seekers (11/06/2020) Amnesty International. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gfr79r, the Centre for Peace Studies[9]Report on Pushbacks and Violence From the Republic of Croatia: Illegal Practices and Systemic Human Rights Violations at EU Borders. (03/04/2019) Center for Peace Studies. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HHzziF and Are You Syrious (AYS) have drawn attention to the Croatian border police’s excessive use of violence. Countless international media including; Radio Free Europe[10]https://pr.fo/2HQ6YHs, Al Jazeera Balkans[11] Migranti prijavljuju nove slučajeve nasilja hrvatske policije (18/12/2019) Al Jazeera Balkans. Available at: https://pr.fo/34KMQQ2, Deutsche Welle[12]Izbjeglica: „Hrvatski policajci su me tjerali da plivam nazad u Bosnu, a ne znam!” (17/07/2019). DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3MCRH, and the Swiss public broadcaster SRF[13]Prügel an der EU-Grenze: Wie Kroatien Migranten abschiebt (15/05/2019). SRF. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HQIi1X have also documented asylum seekers’ testimonies of their treatment in Croatia. These reports, often corroborated by aid workers and physicians, reveal an unprecedented degree the level of brutality used by the Croatian border police in their treatment of migrants and refugees near the border with BiH. Croatian outlet Dnevnik was further able to obtain a testimony by a local police officer, largely confirming the wrongdoing of the border police[14]Policajac priznao za DNEVNIK.hr da uhvaćene migrante po naredbi šefova vraćaju na granicu. (21/10/2019). Dnevnik.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jGBfG5. The Croatian police’s track record of torture, humiliation, and abuse of asylum seekers[15]Croatia: Fresh evidence of police abuse and torture of migrants and asylum-seekers. (11/06/2020). Amnesty International. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gfr79r, using practices such as spray-painting the heads of those caught attempting to cross the border with red crosses[16]Tondo, Lorenzo (28/05/2020). Crosses on our heads to ‘cure’ Covid-19: refugees report abuse by Croatian police. The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jNBVJA, or shooting at migrants[17]Jamieson, Alistair (18/11/2019) Migrant shot by Croatian police in mountains near Slovenian border. EuroNews & Reuters. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oRvfOD is mounting. Unfortunately, the Croatian police are not an exception, they are rather, the rule. The Border Violence Monitoring Network, which since 2016 has consistently monitoredhuman rights violations at the external borders of the European Union, in its latest report from September 2020, documented 40 cases of pushbacks, affecting 1548 people in Greece and along the Balkan Route, including Romanian, Austrian and international (primarily Czech) police units in North Macedonia[18]Illegal Push-backs and Border Violence Reports: Balkan Region (2020) Border Violence Monitoring Network. Available at: https://pr.fo/35UNoCc.

On 22 October, the EU Commissioner for Home Affairs, Ylva Johansson tweeted that after reviewing the Danish Refugee Council’s report[19]Gadzo, Mersiha (22/10/2020) Refugees allege physical, sexual abuse by Croatian authorities. Al Jazeera. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HKJvaF on the pushbacks by the Croatian police, she is planning to discuss the matter with the Croatian authorities.

Reviewing the comments, which speakers of the local languages (Bosnian, Croatian, Serbian) have left on the media websites and their social media accounts under the reports about border police violence, it becomes evident that opinions are divided along the two main narratives. A sizeable portion of users seemingly enjoy the stories and cheer on the police violence, with comments such as “Go Croatia!”, “Bravo, Croatian police!” in reaction to reports on abusive practices. They often refer to the migrants using hateful and dehumanising language, branding them as ISIS terrorists or comparing them to a zombie invasion. Another category of internet user justifies the violent pushback on administrative grounds, using the (flawed) arguments of reciprocity and equivalence. They find it unfair that people are attempting to cross borders without documents when they similarly would not be allowed to enter other countries without valid travel documents. Finally, there are users who show empathy for migrants and often lash out at other commenters.

While migrants have to bear the brunt of the harassment by authorities, those attempting to help, or advocate for refugees, or report about the abuse become secondary targets. Both international and local journalists covering these stories were threatened or fined by the police while documenting the situation along the Balkan route[20]Kazna od 500 KM i zabrana snimanja: Policijaci spriječili novinara Ajdina Kambera u obavljanju posla (24/04/2020). Etrafika. Available at: https://pr.fo/2TD0MoS. Nidzara Ahmetasevic, a Sarajevo-based journalist, in one incident saw police officers knocking down several migrants and refugees to the sidewalk and then taking them into a police vehicle. Police officers threatened Ahmetasevic with a fine, even after she identified herself as a journalist[21]Policajci u Sarajevu napali novinarku (17/06/2020) Oslobodjenje. Available at: https://pr.fo/2JpjqPi. An account of how authorities prevent access for journalists and obstruct their work, was described by Deutsche Welle journalist, Ajdin Kamber, who describes the experiences of being ejected from government buildings and being harassed by the police as he (and others) try to do his job[22]Kamber, Ajdin (06/11/2019). Zašto je novinar DW-a nepoželjan u vladi USK-a?. DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3SYpm. Human rights defenders and journalists who report on the situation in Una-Sana canton and migration issues in the region are also viciously targeted online. Vanja Stokic, an editor-in-chief of the eTrafika.net portal, was threatened in the comments under a photo she posted on her Facebook profile. The commenter explicitly mentions “cutting off heads,” using numerous expletives for both the migrants and those who help them. Stokic reported it to the police and the suspect was arrested[23]Lulić, Stevan. (24/05/2020) Uhapšen osumnjičeni za prijetnje Vanji Stokić .Nezavisne Novine. Available at: https://pr.fo/31YrQUj, though the prosecutor later dropped the case on the grounds that it does not meet the criteria to qualify as either the criminal offence of endangering security or incitement to hate and violence[24]Tomić, Nataša. (28/05/2020) Društvo novinara BiH osudilo prijetnje smrću Vanji Stokić. Etrafika. Available at: https://pr.fo/37YHW3S.


Media Stunts, Border Patrols, and Parliamentary Debates of Far-Right Extremists and Populists

The European far-right media also regularly report on the desperate situation in Greek refugee camps and tensions along the migration routes, weaponising the refugees’ / migrants’ suffering to spread anti-migration propaganda. After Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan opened the country’s borders with eastern Greece[25]van Hagen, Isobel. (29/02/2020) Turkey opens borders with Europe as tensions rise with Syria and Russia. ABC News. Available at: https://pr.fo/3mL1rkR, Austrian and German far-right extremists revisited their media-stunts playbook and in March, shortly before Greece went into coronavirus lockdown, they travelled to Greece to “report” about the situation at the Turkish/Greek border.

The CovertAction Magazine reported the first group of eight to ten people, most of them members of far-right Identitarian Movement from Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, arrived at the Greek border with Turkey on the Evros river in early March[26]Rivera, Ellen. (29/04/2020) European Far Right and Identitarians Exploit Greek Immigration Crisis. Covert Action Magazine. https://pr.fo/2TFdS53, followed by a trickle of several other individuals and groups, visiting Lesbos and the camp Moria, which continued up until August.

According to one of the activists, the purpose of these trips was to meet with Greek patriots, to show solidarity and support.[27]Wessels, Till-Lucas. (19/03/2020). An der Grenze Europas. Sezession. Availalable at: https://archive.is/RrlRE In reality, the images and footage from the trips were used to promote hateful propaganda, portraying refugees as invaders, “dangerous soldiers of Islam” who came to destroy Europe.[28]Schützen wir Griechenlands Grenzen! (03/03/2020). Identitäre Bewegung Deutschland. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUO-zOIAP6s The far-right activists used different social media platform for the promotion of these materials, creating videos and articles, using hashtags such as  #IstandWithGreece[29]#IStandWithGreece hashtag gathers waves of support for Greece on refugee crisis. (03/03/2020). Neos Kosmos. Available at: https://pr.fo/37Zt4lJ and #niewieder2015[30]Schützt unsere Grenzen Nie wieder 2015! (2020). Die Oesterreicher. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oLSnhp.

In Slovenia, a group of anti-migration activists, consisting of assorted far-right extremists and ex-convicts, formed a paramilitary unit in 2018, named ‘Stajerska Varda’ (Styrian Guard)[31]Patriot games: Slovenian paramilitaries face down migrant ‘threat’ on border. (11/11/2019) Reuters. Available at: https://pr.fo/37YOIXi. Presenting itself as a civil initiative and a voluntary defence community, the group patrols the borders with Croatia and Italy with an objective to intercept migrants attempting to cross the border illegally.  In September, the amendments to the State Border Control Law and the Law on the Protection of Public Order were adopted, prohibiting individuals and groups from “controlling the state’s borders similar to police duties”[32]Poslanci podprli zakonska predloga za omejitev delovanja t. i. vard. (24/08/2020). Slovenske Novice. Available at: https://pr.fo/34KNVay but other than that, authorities did little to prevent the activities of these anti-migration vigilante patrols. As of today, Stajerska Varda continues their border interventions and is consistently promoting its anti-migration views and military-like activities on their Facebook page.

Groups with similar missions are also self-organising in Serbia. An informal group calling itself ‘Narodne Patrole’ (People’s Patrols) was handing out leaflets to migrants in the center of Belgrade, “informing” them that their freedom of movement is restricted due to frequent attacks on Serbian girls and women[33]Narodne patrole u centru Beograda – pogledajte njihov razgovor sa emigrantima. (22/02/2020) Srbin.info. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4P_l6pvUmA.  The group has a very active Facebook presence and also uses other social media accounts for organizing public events, such as the recent “Let’s clean the park” rally, advertised with a picture of a park with migrants in it. Another group engaging in similar activities is ‘Nacionalna obrana Levijatan’ (National Defence Levijatan), a part of the wider Levijatan movement in Serbia that unsuccessfully ran in recent parliamentary elections. According to its leader, their goal is “to put migrants on notice when they are misbehaving, without using violence or harassing anyone.”[34]Stošić, Petar (13/07/2020) Lider Levijatana iznosi svoju stranu priče: Koji to fašisti grade kuću Romima? IndexHR. Available at: https://pr.fo/34L8QtW

The far-right and populist anti-immigration activists visiting Greece’s borders and refugee camps for a photo opportunity, patrolling the forests of Slovenia and streets of Serbia, exploit the current humanitarian crisis as an opportunity for self-promotion. They create a spectacle, using misleading and manipulative content to amplify their message, hoping to gain new supporters.

While the groups patrolling the borders or the streets in the countries along the Balkan route can be dismissed as fringe and most are, at least declaratively, disavowed by government representatives and parties in the EU countries won, have nevertheless, won seats in the national parliaments on vociferous anti-migration platforms. They have been normalising the narratives of migrant pushback and repressions, while preventing a humane, sustainable, EU-wide solution to migration.

The Austrian Freedom Party (FPÖ), a junior partner in the government between 2017 and 2019, regularly stirs domestic anti-migrant sentiment, running controversial ads in print media and online. The party leadership commonly refers to migration as “creeping Islamisation” and “population displacement.”

In Germany, the anti-migration, racist, and xenophobic rhetoric has helped the political party, ‘Alternative for Germany’ enter the Bundestag in 2017 and become the largest opposition party. It appealed to voters with an overtly Islamophobic campaign and fearmongering around migration[35]Wildman, Sarah. (31/08/2020). The German far right is running Islamophobic ads starring women in bikinis. Vox. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HI77gE, although it recently fired a prominent figure, Christian Lueth, after he was recorded saying that migrants coming to the country could be shot or gassed[36]Far-right German politician sacked for reportedly suggesting migrants could be killed. (28/09/2020). The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/37Y9A19.

In Croatia, the newly formed populist ethno-nationalist Homeland Movement, formed around the unsuccessful presidential candidate and popular singer Miroslav Skoro, entered the parliament in July this year, finishing third. Even though migration was not the dominant theme of the campaign, they are generally in favour of tough, restrictive migration policies. In Slovenia, where politicians are likelwise distancing themselves from openly anti-migration rethoric, their most important media mouthpieces are not. Specifically, most influential media around the leading conservative SDS party, such as online portals ‘Democracy’, tabloid ‘Škandal24.si,’ and the TV channel Nova24.tv have been publishing Islamophobic content, using it with the aim of stirring outrage at covered children spotted in a park in the center of Ljubljana[37]V Ljubljani v rjuho zavite že majhne punčke! (30/08/2018). Skandal24. Available at: https://pr.fo/2TFutWj ,warning against dangers to democracy by electing politicians with immigrant backgrounds[38]Muslimani na Švedskem želijo prevzeti državo: “Vi imate ure, mi pa imamo čas”. (19/09/2018) Demokracija. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jIjEO0, or arguing that the Muslim immigrants’ contribution to the society is to “bring third world diseases, danger of terrorist attacks, and sexual assaults on women.”[39]NE, HVALA! Društvo slovenskih pisateljev vam ponuja možnost: “Spoznajte muslimana!”. (12/04/2018). NovaTV24. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oGEyR7

Dominik Nepp, a Viennese city councilor and the leader of FPO in Vienna, ran an ad in September, ahead of the State elections in Vienna,[40]Dominic Nepp Ads (15/09/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/35PJ5Iu depicting a dark, masked figure with a knife in the background and a (white) woman screaming in fear in the forefront, accompanied by the following text “it is a fact that with the mass migration of 2015, Vienna became an absolute stronghold of crime.” He spent between 300-400 EUR on this particular message to reach between 80,000-90,000 people in Vienna. Between 28 Mar 2019 – 26 Oct 2020, his page spent over 200,000 EUR on Facebook ads. In May, he ran a series of ads targeting the entire Austria. According to the data provided by Facebook, his campaign spent between 15,800 to 22,295 EUR on only eight ads, each containing clear anti-migration and Islamophobic messages. One of the ads depicts a crowded inflatable raft boat, with a slogan “Sea rescue is human smuggling.”[41]Dominic Nepp Ads (18/05/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gjt7h4 Another shows a young couple, the woman wearing a headscarf.[42]Dominic Nepp Ads (18/05/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oMnOYC  The message on this ad simply reads – “stop the immigration”.


The Public Reacts: Online Mobilisation and Protests around Migration Issues

Many migrants stranded in the Una-Sana Canton, right outside the EU’s external border between BiH and Croatia, have to live outside of officially designated reception centres, in appalling conditions, without electricity and water.[43]Kamp iz Noćne More: Migranti u BiH žive u teškim uslovima i nemaju šta da jedu! Organizacije upozoravaju da im preti humanitarna katastrofa! (VIDEO). (24/10/2019). Kurir.rs. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oGaeGm The humanitarian crisis escalates periodically with worsening weather conditions and was this year further compounded by the COVID19 pandemic. To make matters worse, the reception centres were forcibly emptied at the end of September, ahead of elections in November, ostensibly due to public pressure[44]Sharma, Aditya (01/10/2020). Bosnia: Authorities evict hundreds from UN-run migrant camp. Deutsche Welle. Available at: https://pr.fo/3egX65U. The action was strongly condemned by the EU, which provides funding for these facilities[45]EU statement – Transfer of refugees and migrants from Bira. (01/10/2020). IOM Bosnia and Herzegovina. Available at: https://pr.fo/3efHRtC.

Desperate, with nowhere to go the migrants are locked in a vicious cycle of mistrust, fear, and increasing violence with the local populations. The unmet and mismanaged public safety concerns of the local population on the one hand, and the basic needs of the migrant population on the other, are inevitably leading to friction between residents and people in transit, all of which is fueled by misinformation and propaganda by extremists and populists. Fear, in combination with anger towards authorities for not being able to solve the problem, contributes to the appeal of the anti-migration narrative. Public gatherings against migrants and refugees, are sometimes organized by the local politicians who use trumped up numbers related to reported crimes committed by migrants[46]Ramić, Ser. (29/08/2020). Antimigrantski narativ: Manipulacije brojem krivičnih djela u USK. Istinomjer.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oL36Z9. In Bihac in August hundreds of citizens gathered in the town square and demanded that the authorities solve the problem of “irregular migrants and the prevention of the influx of new migrants in the region”[47]Hiljade Ljudi Na Protestima U Bihaću: Očistite Naš Grad, Ulice I Mjesne Zajednice Od Migranata, Lopova, Narkomana… (29/08/2020) Crna Hronika. Available at: https://pr.fo/322SgUW.  

Protests against migrants also happened in Velika Kladusa, a town about 10 kilometres from the Croatian border. Citizens also began to organise online, where closed Facebook groups with titles like “Stop the invasion of migrants” or “Stop illegal migrants” were created for and by local citizens to share information, news updates, and personal experiences related to the migrant crisis. For example, a piece of news published by a local portal about 30 migrants arriving by bus from Sarajevo in late August, violating the cantonal government’s movement restrictions[48]Litrić, Azra. (21/08/2020). Uprkos mjerama USK: Autobus iz Sarajeva dovezao 30 migranata u Krajinu. MojCazin.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3221W1X, was shared to a public page followed by over 50,000 people, where it inspired not only calls for violence and online hate speech, but also offline action.

Self-appointed vigilantes and groups are increasingly taking matters in their own hands, under the pretext of protecting safety of other and public order. Following news such as the one about new migrants’ arrival circulating online, the situation in Velika Kladusa escalated. Locals began blocking traffic, intercepting buses, and dragging out migrants they found among the passengers[49]Kod Velike Kladuše mještani ponovo izašli na ulicu, čekaju autobuse s migrantima. (18/08/2020). Klix.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HRwvjV. Bus and taxi drivers transporting migrants, as well as volunteers and aid workers were targeted after their personal details and photos were published in these private groups. Media also reported other violent incidents and a pervasive atmosphere of fear in town[50]Mrkić-Radević, Branka. (21/08/2020). LOV NA MIGRANTE U KRAJINI (FOTO): Nikada nije bilo gore, tuku ih gdje stignu! Žurnal.info. Available at: https://pr.fo/35JKn7C.  

A man who was filmed as he assaulted a bus with migrants in Velika Kladusa[51]MUŠKARAC DASKOM POLUPAO PROZORE AUTOBUSA KOJI JE PREVOZIO MIGRANTE: Snimljen incident u Velikoj Kladuši. (16/08/2020). Kurir.rs. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Ge2eef was celebrated as a hero among anti-migrant activists, both at public gatherings[52]“SVI SMO MI BAJKIN!”: Pogledajte kako je u Velikoj Kladuši dočekan Sead Karajić koji je vratio autobus s migrantima. (17/08/2020). USN. https://pr.fo/3jEw8pK and online. Also near Velika Kladusa, as a result of an arson attack with Molotov cocktails on a makeshift accommodation, five migrants were almost burned alive[53]Elias-Bursac, Ellen. (10/08/2020) AYS Weekend Digest 8–9/8/2020: Bosnia, shocking attempt to burn asylum seekers alive. Medium. Available at: https://pr.fo/37ZuAUX. Another migrant was seriously wounded with knife in Sarajevo in September and local man was arrested for attempted murder[54]Sarajevo: Migrant teško ranjen nožem, uhapšen bh. Državljanin (03/09/2020). Klix.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/2GiDMIQ.

After the Europe’s largest refugee camp, Moria[55]Moria refugee camp. (19/10/2020). Wikipedia. https://pr.fo/3kLNGBB (on the Greek island of Lesbos), burned to the ground in early September, thousands of people marched in the streets, of  Berlin[56]Jachmann, Luis Nicolas. (21/09/2020). “Wir haben Platz” – Tausende fordern Aufnahme von mehr Geflüchteten aus Moria. Euronews. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jKWuGP, Vienna[57]“Wir haben Platz” in Wien: Demo für Flüchtlinge aus Moria. (03/10/2020) Vienna Online. Available at: https://pr.fo/37ZuWuL, but also in other German cities  such as Cologne, Munich, and Leipzig, as well as in Paris, France[58]Thousands march in Berlin to demand Germany take in Moria refugees. (21/09/2020). DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://pr.fo/3ehrNaT, calling on authorities to take in more of the over 12,000 who were left without a shelter since the fire. Protesters held up signs saying Wir haben platz/We have room, or EU-Politik tötet/EU Politics kills.


Conclusion

Public discourse and narratives around migration develop in the context of government action. The anti-migration public discourse and narratives thrive in a situation of government inaction and policy failure. While propaganda and misinformation also contribute to fueling resentment and mobilising action, civic engagement – both vigilante justice and acts of solidarity and altruism – is usually motivated by what the public perceives as lacking.

The complexity of the migration-related problems and the tainted history of attempts to solve them in Europe puts far right activists and populist politicians at a distinct advantage. As the ousted AfD spokesperson Christian Lueth aptly put it in an interview that cost him his position, the worse off Germany is, the better for his party[59]Fuchs, Christian. (28/08/2020) “Je schlechter es Deutschland geht, desto besser für die AfD”. Zeit Online. Available at:  https://pr.fo/2TCzb7o.

On the one hand, the far-right parliamentary parties spend money on anti-immigrant ads on Facebook and in the print media, spreading misinformation and propaganda, and many alt-media outlets, are systematically pushing out stories to incite hate and violence, often using the infrastructure of social media platforms. Citizens using private groups are sharing these stories, fostering atmosphere in which calls to defend the communities have led to violence against migrants trapped in Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia. On the other hand, Initiatives such as COURAGE – Mut zur Menschlichkeit[60]COURAGE – Mut zur Menschlichkeit. (2020). Respekt.net. Available at: https://pr.fo/35S6n0o, attempting to bring people from the burnt down Moria to safety in Austria, through crowdfunding sustainable accommodation and care, show the existing capacity and the good will of ordinary citizens.

While policies to address the incitement of hate and violence on the platforms should be improved, they will do little to curb the migration-related violence as long as flashpoints and bottlenecks like Moria or camps in Una-Sana Canton in Bosnia Herzegovina continue to exist. The festering of humanitarian crisis at and outside of Europe’s borders, the normalisation of the status-quo of squalid, inhumane conditions in refugee camps and the EU’s collective failure to effectively respond to the migration crisis have far reaching consequences. The EU Pact on Migration and Asylum[61]New Pact on Migration and Asylum: A fresh start on migration in Europe. (2020). European Commissionhttps://pr.fo/35Rgh2b announced on 23 of September, as the Commission’s new approach to migration, in addition to solving technical hurdles of the asylum process, should also endeavour to shift the narrative around migration, thus far dominated by the far right and populist messages, in the direction of solidarity.


This article has been produced as part of the Resonant Voices Initiative in the EU, funded by the European Union’s Internal Security Fund – Police.

The content of this article represents the views of the author and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Commission does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

References

1 Greece sea and land arrivals monthly: Operations Portal. (2020) UNHCR. Available at: https://pr.fo/34HpT00
2 Kingsley, Patrick. (09/03/2016) Balkan countries shut borders as attention turns to new refugee routes. The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/34HlIl2
3 According to the International Rescue Committee, Available at: https://pr.fo/2TFsu4j
4 Fighting over the Slovenian Border Barrier (2020). Deutsche Welle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3hSmm
5 Albert, Rénes. (27/08/2020). Slovenia sends 1,000 police to Croatian border to halt migrant wave. Remix. Available at: https://pr.fo/35UMaH6
6 IOM’s Migration Response (2020) IOM Bosnia and Herzegovina. Available at: https://pr.fo/3kJRrrr
7 Croatia: Asylum Seekers Forced Back to Serbia (20/01/2017) Human Rights Watch. Available at: https://pr.fo/31XnVa0; Croatia: Migrants Pushed Back to Bosnia and Herzegovina (11/12/2018) Human Rights Watch. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HNxCkq
8 Croatia: Fresh evidence of police abuse and torture of migrants and asylum seekers (11/06/2020) Amnesty International. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gfr79r
9 Report on Pushbacks and Violence From the Republic of Croatia: Illegal Practices and Systemic Human Rights Violations at EU Borders. (03/04/2019) Center for Peace Studies. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HHzziF
10 https://pr.fo/2HQ6YHs
11 Migranti prijavljuju nove slučajeve nasilja hrvatske policije (18/12/2019) Al Jazeera Balkans. Available at: https://pr.fo/34KMQQ2
12 Izbjeglica: „Hrvatski policajci su me tjerali da plivam nazad u Bosnu, a ne znam!” (17/07/2019). DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3MCRH
13 Prügel an der EU-Grenze: Wie Kroatien Migranten abschiebt (15/05/2019). SRF. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HQIi1X
14 Policajac priznao za DNEVNIK.hr da uhvaćene migrante po naredbi šefova vraćaju na granicu. (21/10/2019). Dnevnik.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jGBfG5
15 Croatia: Fresh evidence of police abuse and torture of migrants and asylum-seekers. (11/06/2020). Amnesty International. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gfr79r
16 Tondo, Lorenzo (28/05/2020). Crosses on our heads to ‘cure’ Covid-19: refugees report abuse by Croatian police. The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jNBVJA
17 Jamieson, Alistair (18/11/2019) Migrant shot by Croatian police in mountains near Slovenian border. EuroNews & Reuters. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oRvfOD
18 Illegal Push-backs and Border Violence Reports: Balkan Region (2020) Border Violence Monitoring Network. Available at: https://pr.fo/35UNoCc
19 Gadzo, Mersiha (22/10/2020) Refugees allege physical, sexual abuse by Croatian authorities. Al Jazeera. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HKJvaF
20 Kazna od 500 KM i zabrana snimanja: Policijaci spriječili novinara Ajdina Kambera u obavljanju posla (24/04/2020). Etrafika. Available at: https://pr.fo/2TD0MoS
21 Policajci u Sarajevu napali novinarku (17/06/2020) Oslobodjenje. Available at: https://pr.fo/2JpjqPi
22 Kamber, Ajdin (06/11/2019). Zašto je novinar DW-a nepoželjan u vladi USK-a?. DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3SYpm
23 Lulić, Stevan. (24/05/2020) Uhapšen osumnjičeni za prijetnje Vanji Stokić .Nezavisne Novine. Available at: https://pr.fo/31YrQUj
24 Tomić, Nataša. (28/05/2020) Društvo novinara BiH osudilo prijetnje smrću Vanji Stokić. Etrafika. Available at: https://pr.fo/37YHW3S
25 van Hagen, Isobel. (29/02/2020) Turkey opens borders with Europe as tensions rise with Syria and Russia. ABC News. Available at: https://pr.fo/3mL1rkR
26 Rivera, Ellen. (29/04/2020) European Far Right and Identitarians Exploit Greek Immigration Crisis. Covert Action Magazine. https://pr.fo/2TFdS53
27 Wessels, Till-Lucas. (19/03/2020). An der Grenze Europas. Sezession. Availalable at: https://archive.is/RrlRE
28 Schützen wir Griechenlands Grenzen! (03/03/2020). Identitäre Bewegung Deutschland. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUO-zOIAP6s
29 #IStandWithGreece hashtag gathers waves of support for Greece on refugee crisis. (03/03/2020). Neos Kosmos. Available at: https://pr.fo/37Zt4lJ
30 Schützt unsere Grenzen Nie wieder 2015! (2020). Die Oesterreicher. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oLSnhp
31 Patriot games: Slovenian paramilitaries face down migrant ‘threat’ on border. (11/11/2019) Reuters. Available at: https://pr.fo/37YOIXi
32 Poslanci podprli zakonska predloga za omejitev delovanja t. i. vard. (24/08/2020). Slovenske Novice. Available at: https://pr.fo/34KNVay
33 Narodne patrole u centru Beograda – pogledajte njihov razgovor sa emigrantima. (22/02/2020) Srbin.info. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4P_l6pvUmA
34 Stošić, Petar (13/07/2020) Lider Levijatana iznosi svoju stranu priče: Koji to fašisti grade kuću Romima? IndexHR. Available at: https://pr.fo/34L8QtW
35 Wildman, Sarah. (31/08/2020). The German far right is running Islamophobic ads starring women in bikinis. Vox. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HI77gE
36 Far-right German politician sacked for reportedly suggesting migrants could be killed. (28/09/2020). The Guardian. Available at: https://pr.fo/37Y9A19
37 V Ljubljani v rjuho zavite že majhne punčke! (30/08/2018). Skandal24. Available at: https://pr.fo/2TFutWj
38 Muslimani na Švedskem želijo prevzeti državo: “Vi imate ure, mi pa imamo čas”. (19/09/2018) Demokracija. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jIjEO0
39 NE, HVALA! Društvo slovenskih pisateljev vam ponuja možnost: “Spoznajte muslimana!”. (12/04/2018). NovaTV24. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oGEyR7
40 Dominic Nepp Ads (15/09/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/35PJ5Iu
41 Dominic Nepp Ads (18/05/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Gjt7h4
42 Dominic Nepp Ads (18/05/2020) Facebook Ad Library. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oMnOYC
43 Kamp iz Noćne More: Migranti u BiH žive u teškim uslovima i nemaju šta da jedu! Organizacije upozoravaju da im preti humanitarna katastrofa! (VIDEO). (24/10/2019). Kurir.rs. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oGaeGm
44 Sharma, Aditya (01/10/2020). Bosnia: Authorities evict hundreds from UN-run migrant camp. Deutsche Welle. Available at: https://pr.fo/3egX65U
45 EU statement – Transfer of refugees and migrants from Bira. (01/10/2020). IOM Bosnia and Herzegovina. Available at: https://pr.fo/3efHRtC
46 Ramić, Ser. (29/08/2020). Antimigrantski narativ: Manipulacije brojem krivičnih djela u USK. Istinomjer.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3oL36Z9
47 Hiljade Ljudi Na Protestima U Bihaću: Očistite Naš Grad, Ulice I Mjesne Zajednice Od Migranata, Lopova, Narkomana… (29/08/2020) Crna Hronika. Available at: https://pr.fo/322SgUW
48 Litrić, Azra. (21/08/2020). Uprkos mjerama USK: Autobus iz Sarajeva dovezao 30 migranata u Krajinu. MojCazin.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/3221W1X
49 Kod Velike Kladuše mještani ponovo izašli na ulicu, čekaju autobuse s migrantima. (18/08/2020). Klix.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/2HRwvjV
50 Mrkić-Radević, Branka. (21/08/2020). LOV NA MIGRANTE U KRAJINI (FOTO): Nikada nije bilo gore, tuku ih gdje stignu! Žurnal.info. Available at: https://pr.fo/35JKn7C
51 MUŠKARAC DASKOM POLUPAO PROZORE AUTOBUSA KOJI JE PREVOZIO MIGRANTE: Snimljen incident u Velikoj Kladuši. (16/08/2020). Kurir.rs. Available at: https://pr.fo/2Ge2eef
52 “SVI SMO MI BAJKIN!”: Pogledajte kako je u Velikoj Kladuši dočekan Sead Karajić koji je vratio autobus s migrantima. (17/08/2020). USN. https://pr.fo/3jEw8pK
53 Elias-Bursac, Ellen. (10/08/2020) AYS Weekend Digest 8–9/8/2020: Bosnia, shocking attempt to burn asylum seekers alive. Medium. Available at: https://pr.fo/37ZuAUX
54 Sarajevo: Migrant teško ranjen nožem, uhapšen bh. Državljanin (03/09/2020). Klix.ba. Available at: https://pr.fo/2GiDMIQ
55 Moria refugee camp. (19/10/2020). Wikipedia. https://pr.fo/3kLNGBB
56 Jachmann, Luis Nicolas. (21/09/2020). “Wir haben Platz” – Tausende fordern Aufnahme von mehr Geflüchteten aus Moria. Euronews. Available at: https://pr.fo/3jKWuGP
57 “Wir haben Platz” in Wien: Demo für Flüchtlinge aus Moria. (03/10/2020) Vienna Online. Available at: https://pr.fo/37ZuWuL
58 Thousands march in Berlin to demand Germany take in Moria refugees. (21/09/2020). DeutscheWelle. Available at: https://pr.fo/3ehrNaT
59 Fuchs, Christian. (28/08/2020) “Je schlechter es Deutschland geht, desto besser für die AfD”. Zeit Online. Available at:  https://pr.fo/2TCzb7o
60 COURAGE – Mut zur Menschlichkeit. (2020). Respekt.net. Available at: https://pr.fo/35S6n0o
61 New Pact on Migration and Asylum: A fresh start on migration in Europe. (2020). European Commissionhttps://pr.fo/35Rgh2b